Saturday, 2 June 2012
Discipline - is supernanny right? NCT newsletter piece
Discipline
Before you read this article, I have a request. Please avoid thinking about white bears for the next ten minutes. I’ll tell you why later.
Unlike most areas of psychology, there is a lot of agreement as to what works in improving children’s behaviour. The evidence is based on what we know about how we learn. There are two main ways: through imitation, or social modelling, and through conditioning. The key principle of conditioning theory is the law of effect: behaviours that have positive outcomes will increase in frequency, while behaviours that have negative outcomes will reduce in frequency. This is true for all animals, from dogs to snails to toddlers! It’s a hugely simple and hugely powerful principle. You don’t need to worry about whether your child is ‘being wilful’ or ‘didn’t mean it’, you just respond to the behaviour.
An important factor is to think about what constitutes a ‘positive outcome’ from a child’s point of view. One of the most valuable things a child can receive is your attention. There’s probably a strong evolutionary reason for this – children who keep their parents’ attention on them were less likely to get eaten by sabre-tooth tigers! Positive attention is more valued than negative attention, of course, but negative attention is often better than being ignored.
These principles lead to a set of fairly clear guidelines. First, giving regular positive attention throughout the day means that negative attention is less ‘rewarding’. That’s why Supernanny is always getting her families to do activities with lots of praise and fun, as well as discipline. Second, often the most effective discipline is to remove attention – for example, by putting a child in ‘time out’. Third, consistency is key. If your child is hitting, for example, but you only discipline them some of the time, it will take longer to reduce the behaviour.
The other type of learning, imitation, has its own implications. As you’ve probably noticed, children imitate very efficiently. That’s one reason why smacking isn’t recommended, because children are likely to copy the behaviour. Therefore it’s best to pick a discipline strategy that you would be happy for your child to copy!
And now back to the white bears. Did you manage to avoid thinking about them? I bet you had at least one thought. A classic study using that approach showed it’s often easier to ‘do’ something than to ‘not do’ something. If I’d told you to think a lot about white bears, then that would be much easier. And for young children, thinking about something normally leads to doing it, as children find it hard to inhibit behaviour. Therefore try and make your requests positive (e.g. stroke the cat gently) rather than negative (e.g. don’t hit the cat) whenever you can.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment