Thursday, 13 January 2011

baby signing

We've taught our little boy, R, baby sign. He and I did a class of sing and sign for a term, then shortly afterwards discovered Something Special, which R loves.

I did signing for a couple of reasons - I thought it would help to be able to communicate more earlier. I was also interested in baby signing from a research point of view. I was interested in how babies learn signs, how they create their own signs, and whether sign acquisition progresses in the same way in spoken language acquisition.

It has been really interesting and at times has given a window into R's thinking in a way that spoken language doesn't at the same age, because the physical process of speaking is so difficult and therefore early spoken words can be difficult to understand.

For example, the other day I gave R some baked beans for lunch, and he signed 'bees' while pointing at the beans. It's an understandable confusion - beans and bees are words that sound similar, and beans are about the same size as bees.

Of course, I am over-interpreting a little - it's a mother's prerogative! But I truly believe that without baby signing I would never have known that R believed beans to be decapitated insects...

Tuesday, 11 January 2011

Virtually everything you decide today will be wrong

The blog title is taken from The Long Dark Teatime of the Soul, by Douglas Adams. If you haven't read it, I urge you to give it a go.

Anyway, that's largely irrelevant. Shortly after choosing the title for this blog, my father sent me an article (this one) which mentions a paper entitled "Why Most Published Research Findings Are False". I decided that issue was a good starting point!


Last year I got pretty low thinking about the many ways psychological research findings can be false. We think of science as objective, but in reality it's often far from that.


In the first place, most findings are based on statistical tests, which are officially 'significant' if they would occur by chance in less than 5% of cases. Of course, if you do 20 tests, 1 would be significant by chance. And many research studies include a lot more comparisons than that! We could set the 'significance' level higher, but of course that doesn't mean that the results aren't due to chance. 


There's the issue of publication bias - it's well known that statistically significant results are more likely to get published. Less obvious is that results that are surprising, but plausible, are the most likely to get published. So new findings that seem to be elegantly explained by a new theory will get published, but once that theory has been around for a while, findings that disprove that theory are more likely to get published. So research goes in waves, 'proving' and 'disproving' ideas in turn.


Finally, studying psychology has it's own issues. Most cognitive terms are in some sense a metaphor, and of course all metaphors are wrong in some ways. For example, I am interested in phonological representations - in the representation of the sound structure of words. After studying them for over 10 years, I have no idea what form these 'representations' take. In reality, no one does. Even if we could pull apart the brain and see the patterns of activation that match up to each word, it wouldn't really answer the questions of how these representations work. There would still be an explanatory gap. 




First Post

Just checking how this fancy-pants modern-style blog works. Only a few short weeks after blogs were denigrated as old style and self obsessed on TV's guide to modern life: How I Met Your Mother.