This is a piece published in my local NCT newsletter, where I have a column named "Psychologists Corner".
More and more of us are choosing to use childcare for our young children, whether that consists of childminders, nurseries or preschools. Often this is an emotionally charged decision, with parents feeling guilty whatever choice they make. So what effect does being in childcare have on children?
Of course, this is a really complex research question to answer. First, you need to study development over time, so it takes a while! Second, there are lots of confounding factors that will also affect other long-term outcomes. Parents who put their children in childcare are likely to be better paid, for example, which means their children are likely to have lots of advantages throughout childhood. Third, there are lots of variables in terms of the childcare – what type of childcare, how long the child is there, how good the childcare is and so on. We need very large-scale studies so that we can take account of all of these variables.
There are a few of these studies going on. The largest UK based study is the Effective Provision of Pre-school Education (EPPE: http://eppe.ioe.ac.uk/). They found that attending preschool from age 3 helped with social and educational development, though parent practices had more of an effect than preschool support.
Another study carried out in the USA (the NICHD early child care research network) includes children followed since they were 1 month old, allowing us to look at very early effects. They also measured the quality of the childcare with observations. Children in high quality childcare showed slightly better educational outcomes throughout childhood, and children in childcare for a long time showed slightly worse behaviour. In both cases, childcare explained about 3% of the variance in outcome scores, so only a small effect.
Finally, this study has shown a further set of variables that we need to take into account – the personality of the child. Children with ‘difficult temperaments’ are particularly affected by the quality of the childcare. These are children who were grumpy and easily upset as babies. For the more relaxed children, the quality of childcare doesn’t have much of an effect. The more anxious children, however, are highly affected by the care they experience. Sensitive, responsive care meant that these children showed better than average outcomes, while unresponsive care had the opposite effect.
To sum up, there’s no easy answer to the question of the effect childcare has on children. We know that a lot depends on the individual child and family. We also know that childcare can be very positive for children. Most importantly, we know that quality of care is important, in terms of the caregivers’ knowledge and support in particular. So when you’re picking a childcare setting, look for somewhere where you feel that the staff are kind, knowledgeable and positive. That way you can relax and feel comfortable while you let someone else clean up all that messy play, rather than having it in your own house!