Friday, 4 February 2011

Great expectations?

On Wednesday on the Chris Evans show, Howard Jacobson, winner on the Man Booker prize 2010, told the story about how he became a writer. Apparently after he had written a good story at primary school, his teacher wrote to his parents saying that he had a great future as a writer. His mother framed the note and put it where everyone could see it. Imagine: from the age of seven, he had a clear ambition mapped out which anyone in the family could see. How would it feel if one day his mum had taken the note down?

A recent book has hit the headlines arguing the benefits of high expectations for our children. According to Amy Chua, Chinese parents assume that if their child doesn't achieve well, its because they didn't try hard enough. In other words, Chinese parents have a strong belief in the high underlying abilities of their children. She argues that while Western parents are concerned with not damaging their child's self esteem, often by not telling them the truth about their achievements, it is actually better for a child to do it the Chinese way - assume that if a child doesn't do well it is because they haven't tried hard enough. In other words, having high expectations is a good thing, not a bad thing, for a child.

There is some evidence that children of East Asian parents have higher achievements with the same IQ as children of Western parents. And parents who attribute their child's results to their level of effort tend to have higher achieving children.

It seems like maybe saying 'oh well, good effort' when a child does badly isn't a great thing to do. Maybe focusing on not damaging a child's self esteem by criticising them actually backfires. A child feels they can't trust your criticism and feels unsure of their true abilities.

Wednesday, 2 February 2011

Chaos, correlation and cause

I am regularly amazed by the way in which I can read the same research as Oliver James and come to the opposite conclusion. For example, a couple of weeks ago, he wrote this post arguing that we ought to clean our houses more. It's based on this paper, which shows that levels of chaos in a household predict children's behaviour even after accounting for parenting practices. Household chaos was measured by a short questionnaire including statements such as "you can't hear yourself think in this house". A cross-sectional study. Now, surely, it is at least possible that these households are more chaotic BECAUSE they include children with behavioural difficulties, rather than the reverse? This is statistics 101 isn't it? Correlation does not equal causation? Or it might equal reverse causation?

In any case, I don't think its strong enough evidence to make me clean my house.