Virtually everything you decide today will be wrong
Saturday, 2 June 2012
Discipline - is supernanny right? NCT newsletter piece
Discipline
Before you read this article, I have a request. Please avoid thinking about white bears for the next ten minutes. I’ll tell you why later.
Unlike most areas of psychology, there is a lot of agreement as to what works in improving children’s behaviour. The evidence is based on what we know about how we learn. There are two main ways: through imitation, or social modelling, and through conditioning. The key principle of conditioning theory is the law of effect: behaviours that have positive outcomes will increase in frequency, while behaviours that have negative outcomes will reduce in frequency. This is true for all animals, from dogs to snails to toddlers! It’s a hugely simple and hugely powerful principle. You don’t need to worry about whether your child is ‘being wilful’ or ‘didn’t mean it’, you just respond to the behaviour.
An important factor is to think about what constitutes a ‘positive outcome’ from a child’s point of view. One of the most valuable things a child can receive is your attention. There’s probably a strong evolutionary reason for this – children who keep their parents’ attention on them were less likely to get eaten by sabre-tooth tigers! Positive attention is more valued than negative attention, of course, but negative attention is often better than being ignored.
These principles lead to a set of fairly clear guidelines. First, giving regular positive attention throughout the day means that negative attention is less ‘rewarding’. That’s why Supernanny is always getting her families to do activities with lots of praise and fun, as well as discipline. Second, often the most effective discipline is to remove attention – for example, by putting a child in ‘time out’. Third, consistency is key. If your child is hitting, for example, but you only discipline them some of the time, it will take longer to reduce the behaviour.
The other type of learning, imitation, has its own implications. As you’ve probably noticed, children imitate very efficiently. That’s one reason why smacking isn’t recommended, because children are likely to copy the behaviour. Therefore it’s best to pick a discipline strategy that you would be happy for your child to copy!
And now back to the white bears. Did you manage to avoid thinking about them? I bet you had at least one thought. A classic study using that approach showed it’s often easier to ‘do’ something than to ‘not do’ something. If I’d told you to think a lot about white bears, then that would be much easier. And for young children, thinking about something normally leads to doing it, as children find it hard to inhibit behaviour. Therefore try and make your requests positive (e.g. stroke the cat gently) rather than negative (e.g. don’t hit the cat) whenever you can.
Back in the saddle?
After a year or so of dormancy, I've decided to resurrect the blog. Probably partly inspired by being pregnant again, so these issues being back in my mind. I'm going to start by posting some articles I've written for the local NCT newsletter - comments very welcome!
Thursday, 10 November 2011
The effects of childcare on children - NCT newsletter piece
This is a piece published in my local NCT newsletter, where I have a column named "Psychologists Corner".
More and more of us are choosing to use childcare for our young children, whether that consists of childminders, nurseries or preschools. Often this is an emotionally charged decision, with parents feeling guilty whatever choice they make. So what effect does being in childcare have on children?
Of course, this is a really complex research question to answer. First, you need to study development over time, so it takes a while! Second, there are lots of confounding factors that will also affect other long-term outcomes. Parents who put their children in childcare are likely to be better paid, for example, which means their children are likely to have lots of advantages throughout childhood. Third, there are lots of variables in terms of the childcare – what type of childcare, how long the child is there, how good the childcare is and so on. We need very large-scale studies so that we can take account of all of these variables.
There are a few of these studies going on. The largest UK based study is the Effective Provision of Pre-school Education (EPPE: http://eppe.ioe.ac.uk/). They found that attending preschool from age 3 helped with social and educational development, though parent practices had more of an effect than preschool support.
Another study carried out in the USA (the NICHD early child care research network) includes children followed since they were 1 month old, allowing us to look at very early effects. They also measured the quality of the childcare with observations. Children in high quality childcare showed slightly better educational outcomes throughout childhood, and children in childcare for a long time showed slightly worse behaviour. In both cases, childcare explained about 3% of the variance in outcome scores, so only a small effect.
Finally, this study has shown a further set of variables that we need to take into account – the personality of the child. Children with ‘difficult temperaments’ are particularly affected by the quality of the childcare. These are children who were grumpy and easily upset as babies. For the more relaxed children, the quality of childcare doesn’t have much of an effect. The more anxious children, however, are highly affected by the care they experience. Sensitive, responsive care meant that these children showed better than average outcomes, while unresponsive care had the opposite effect.
To sum up, there’s no easy answer to the question of the effect childcare has on children. We know that a lot depends on the individual child and family. We also know that childcare can be very positive for children. Most importantly, we know that quality of care is important, in terms of the caregivers’ knowledge and support in particular. So when you’re picking a childcare setting, look for somewhere where you feel that the staff are kind, knowledgeable and positive. That way you can relax and feel comfortable while you let someone else clean up all that messy play, rather than having it in your own house!
More and more of us are choosing to use childcare for our young children, whether that consists of childminders, nurseries or preschools. Often this is an emotionally charged decision, with parents feeling guilty whatever choice they make. So what effect does being in childcare have on children?
Of course, this is a really complex research question to answer. First, you need to study development over time, so it takes a while! Second, there are lots of confounding factors that will also affect other long-term outcomes. Parents who put their children in childcare are likely to be better paid, for example, which means their children are likely to have lots of advantages throughout childhood. Third, there are lots of variables in terms of the childcare – what type of childcare, how long the child is there, how good the childcare is and so on. We need very large-scale studies so that we can take account of all of these variables.
There are a few of these studies going on. The largest UK based study is the Effective Provision of Pre-school Education (EPPE: http://eppe.ioe.ac.uk/). They found that attending preschool from age 3 helped with social and educational development, though parent practices had more of an effect than preschool support.
Another study carried out in the USA (the NICHD early child care research network) includes children followed since they were 1 month old, allowing us to look at very early effects. They also measured the quality of the childcare with observations. Children in high quality childcare showed slightly better educational outcomes throughout childhood, and children in childcare for a long time showed slightly worse behaviour. In both cases, childcare explained about 3% of the variance in outcome scores, so only a small effect.
Finally, this study has shown a further set of variables that we need to take into account – the personality of the child. Children with ‘difficult temperaments’ are particularly affected by the quality of the childcare. These are children who were grumpy and easily upset as babies. For the more relaxed children, the quality of childcare doesn’t have much of an effect. The more anxious children, however, are highly affected by the care they experience. Sensitive, responsive care meant that these children showed better than average outcomes, while unresponsive care had the opposite effect.
To sum up, there’s no easy answer to the question of the effect childcare has on children. We know that a lot depends on the individual child and family. We also know that childcare can be very positive for children. Most importantly, we know that quality of care is important, in terms of the caregivers’ knowledge and support in particular. So when you’re picking a childcare setting, look for somewhere where you feel that the staff are kind, knowledgeable and positive. That way you can relax and feel comfortable while you let someone else clean up all that messy play, rather than having it in your own house!
Tuesday, 29 March 2011
Government policies?
Well, this blog has not been as busy as I had hoped - uni term got in the way I guess, and talking about psychology in my time off stopped seeming like fun. However, I'm back on the horse now! I recently read the government's new green paper on SEN education (available here). Governments are an easy target, I guess - I feel unprofessional complaining about Oliver James on here, but not the tories!
There are some things I like about the paper: I think a link between health and education is key, particularly for dealing with disorders that cross the boundaries between the two, such as autism, speech and language difficulties and genetic syndromes such as Down syndrome.
On the other hand, I'm nearly always concerned about 'giving parents more choices'. It seems to me that this generally ends up meaning that middle class, proactive parents get better support for their children because they understand the system. Parents with less experience of dealing successfully with authority, on the other hand, get an even poorer deal than they would have in the current system. And since many developmental difficulties run in families, parents of children with (for example) communication difficulties are likely to have communication difficulties themselves. In other words, these children are likely to be doubly disadvantaged in what should be one of the key environments that can ameliorate difficulties.
Anyway, I've left my comments. Despite one of the most complex comments forms I have ever encountered! Now that is definitely not aimed at people with communication difficulties!
There are some things I like about the paper: I think a link between health and education is key, particularly for dealing with disorders that cross the boundaries between the two, such as autism, speech and language difficulties and genetic syndromes such as Down syndrome.
On the other hand, I'm nearly always concerned about 'giving parents more choices'. It seems to me that this generally ends up meaning that middle class, proactive parents get better support for their children because they understand the system. Parents with less experience of dealing successfully with authority, on the other hand, get an even poorer deal than they would have in the current system. And since many developmental difficulties run in families, parents of children with (for example) communication difficulties are likely to have communication difficulties themselves. In other words, these children are likely to be doubly disadvantaged in what should be one of the key environments that can ameliorate difficulties.
Anyway, I've left my comments. Despite one of the most complex comments forms I have ever encountered! Now that is definitely not aimed at people with communication difficulties!
Friday, 4 February 2011
Great expectations?
On Wednesday on the Chris Evans show, Howard Jacobson, winner on the Man Booker prize 2010, told the story about how he became a writer. Apparently after he had written a good story at primary school, his teacher wrote to his parents saying that he had a great future as a writer. His mother framed the note and put it where everyone could see it. Imagine: from the age of seven, he had a clear ambition mapped out which anyone in the family could see. How would it feel if one day his mum had taken the note down?
A recent book has hit the headlines arguing the benefits of high expectations for our children. According to Amy Chua, Chinese parents assume that if their child doesn't achieve well, its because they didn't try hard enough. In other words, Chinese parents have a strong belief in the high underlying abilities of their children. She argues that while Western parents are concerned with not damaging their child's self esteem, often by not telling them the truth about their achievements, it is actually better for a child to do it the Chinese way - assume that if a child doesn't do well it is because they haven't tried hard enough. In other words, having high expectations is a good thing, not a bad thing, for a child.
There is some evidence that children of East Asian parents have higher achievements with the same IQ as children of Western parents. And parents who attribute their child's results to their level of effort tend to have higher achieving children.
It seems like maybe saying 'oh well, good effort' when a child does badly isn't a great thing to do. Maybe focusing on not damaging a child's self esteem by criticising them actually backfires. A child feels they can't trust your criticism and feels unsure of their true abilities.
A recent book has hit the headlines arguing the benefits of high expectations for our children. According to Amy Chua, Chinese parents assume that if their child doesn't achieve well, its because they didn't try hard enough. In other words, Chinese parents have a strong belief in the high underlying abilities of their children. She argues that while Western parents are concerned with not damaging their child's self esteem, often by not telling them the truth about their achievements, it is actually better for a child to do it the Chinese way - assume that if a child doesn't do well it is because they haven't tried hard enough. In other words, having high expectations is a good thing, not a bad thing, for a child.
There is some evidence that children of East Asian parents have higher achievements with the same IQ as children of Western parents. And parents who attribute their child's results to their level of effort tend to have higher achieving children.
It seems like maybe saying 'oh well, good effort' when a child does badly isn't a great thing to do. Maybe focusing on not damaging a child's self esteem by criticising them actually backfires. A child feels they can't trust your criticism and feels unsure of their true abilities.
Wednesday, 2 February 2011
Chaos, correlation and cause
I am regularly amazed by the way in which I can read the same research as Oliver James and come to the opposite conclusion. For example, a couple of weeks ago, he wrote this post arguing that we ought to clean our houses more. It's based on this paper, which shows that levels of chaos in a household predict children's behaviour even after accounting for parenting practices. Household chaos was measured by a short questionnaire including statements such as "you can't hear yourself think in this house". A cross-sectional study. Now, surely, it is at least possible that these households are more chaotic BECAUSE they include children with behavioural difficulties, rather than the reverse? This is statistics 101 isn't it? Correlation does not equal causation? Or it might equal reverse causation?
In any case, I don't think its strong enough evidence to make me clean my house.
In any case, I don't think its strong enough evidence to make me clean my house.
Thursday, 13 January 2011
baby signing
We've taught our little boy, R, baby sign. He and I did a class of sing and sign for a term, then shortly afterwards discovered Something Special, which R loves.
I did signing for a couple of reasons - I thought it would help to be able to communicate more earlier. I was also interested in baby signing from a research point of view. I was interested in how babies learn signs, how they create their own signs, and whether sign acquisition progresses in the same way in spoken language acquisition.
It has been really interesting and at times has given a window into R's thinking in a way that spoken language doesn't at the same age, because the physical process of speaking is so difficult and therefore early spoken words can be difficult to understand.
For example, the other day I gave R some baked beans for lunch, and he signed 'bees' while pointing at the beans. It's an understandable confusion - beans and bees are words that sound similar, and beans are about the same size as bees.
Of course, I am over-interpreting a little - it's a mother's prerogative! But I truly believe that without baby signing I would never have known that R believed beans to be decapitated insects...
I did signing for a couple of reasons - I thought it would help to be able to communicate more earlier. I was also interested in baby signing from a research point of view. I was interested in how babies learn signs, how they create their own signs, and whether sign acquisition progresses in the same way in spoken language acquisition.
It has been really interesting and at times has given a window into R's thinking in a way that spoken language doesn't at the same age, because the physical process of speaking is so difficult and therefore early spoken words can be difficult to understand.
For example, the other day I gave R some baked beans for lunch, and he signed 'bees' while pointing at the beans. It's an understandable confusion - beans and bees are words that sound similar, and beans are about the same size as bees.
Of course, I am over-interpreting a little - it's a mother's prerogative! But I truly believe that without baby signing I would never have known that R believed beans to be decapitated insects...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)